Medicare open enrollment runs from October 15 through December 7 each year — and for high-net-worth retirees, letting it pass without a careful review is one of the most expensive mistakes you can make. The stakes are not the same for everyone. If your household income exceeds certain thresholds, you are already paying Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA) surcharges on top of your base Medicare premiums. A change in income, a large Roth conversion, or even a one-time capital gain can trigger a surcharge increase that costs thousands of dollars per year.

🎧 Prefer to listen to the podcast or watch the video? Jump to listen to the podcast & watch the video.

This post walks through seven specific items every high-net-worth retiree should evaluate before the Medicare open enrollment deadline on December 7. These are not generic reminders — they are the considerations that matter most when your income, portfolio, and tax situation are significantly more complex than the average enrollee.

a mature professional couple sitting at a dining room table with a laptop and Medicare plan documents spread out, reviewing their options carefully — Medicare open enrollment
a mature professional couple sitting at a dining room table with a laptop and Medicare plan documents spread out, reviewing their options carefully

Why Medicare Open Enrollment Matters More for High-Net-Worth Retirees

Most financial media treats Medicare open enrollment as a simple task: compare plans, check your drug formulary, and move on. For families with $1 million or more in investable assets, the analysis is fundamentally different.

Your Medicare costs are not fixed. They adjust annually based on your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) from two years prior. In general, that means your 2026 Medicare premiums are based on your 2024 tax return. A large Roth conversion, a business sale, or a significant capital gain in a prior year can push your premiums into a higher IRMAA bracket — sometimes without you realizing it until you receive your first bill.

The IRMAA Surcharge Problem Affluent Retirees Face

IRMAA is not a marginal cost — it is a step-function surcharge. Cross one income threshold and your Medicare Part B and Part D premiums jump, sometimes by hundreds of dollars per month. For married couples, both spouses pay the surcharge independently, so the household impact is doubled.

This is precisely why Medicare open enrollment cannot be treated as a passive renewal. Any plan changes you make during this window take effect January 1, and aligning your plan selection with your projected income and healthcare needs is a meaningful financial decision.

What Changes During Medicare Open Enrollment

During the October 15 – December 7 enrollment period, you can make the following changes:

  • Switch from Original Medicare (Parts A and B) to a Medicare Advantage plan, or vice versa
  • Switch from one Medicare Advantage plan to another
  • Join, switch, or drop a Medicare Part D prescription drug plan
  • Return to Original Medicare and enroll in a standalone Part D plan

Changes to Medigap (Medicare Supplement) policies are generally not part of this enrollment window and may require medical underwriting outside of guaranteed issue periods. Consult a qualified insurance professional for your specific situation.

1. Review Your IRMAA Bracket and Projected 2027 Income

How IRMAA Surcharges Are Calculated

IRMAA surcharges are determined by your MAGI from two years prior. In general, your 2026 premiums are based on your 2024 tax return and your 2027 premiums on your 2025 return. That also means income you recognize in 2026 (before December 31) generally shows up in your Medicare premiums in 2028.

The income thresholds that trigger IRMAA increase annually with inflation, but the surcharge amounts themselves can be significant. For 2026, the Part B surcharge begins once MAGI exceeds $218,000 for married couples filing jointly or $109,000 for individuals, according to the CMS 2026 Medicare premiums and deductibles fact sheet, which also lists the surcharge at each higher income tier. Part D carries its own income-related surcharge on the same income tiers.

Planning Strategy: The IRMAA Cliff and Income Smoothing

For HNW retirees with flexibility in how much income they recognize each year — through Roth conversions, capital gains harvesting, or required minimum distributions — managing income to stay below an IRMAA threshold can produce meaningful savings. The key is modeling your income trajectory across multiple years, not just the current tax year.

This is an area where working with an advisor who provides comprehensive wealth management services pays dividends. Coordinating a Roth conversion strategy, RMD timing, and Medicare premium planning requires looking at three or four tax years simultaneously.

2. Compare Medicare Advantage vs. Original Medicare for Your Situation

Why HNW Retirees Often Prefer Original Medicare

Medicare Advantage plans are aggressively marketed, and for many enrollees they offer real value. But high-net-worth retirees often find that Original Medicare paired with a Medigap supplement gives them something Medicare Advantage typically cannot: unrestricted access to any provider nationwide who accepts Medicare.

If you travel frequently, maintain a second home in another state, or see specialists at major academic medical centers, Original Medicare’s national coverage is a significant advantage. Medicare Advantage plans are network-based, and out-of-network care — when covered at all — often comes with substantially higher cost-sharing.

When Medicare Advantage May Make Sense

That said, Medicare Advantage plans are not universally inferior. Some plans offer meaningful extras — dental, vision, and hearing benefits that Original Medicare does not cover. If you live in one geographic area, have predictable healthcare needs, and are cost-conscious about premiums, the analysis may favor a well-rated Advantage plan.

The Medicare open enrollment period is the right time to run this comparison with current plan data, not assumptions carried over from prior years. Plans change their networks, benefits, and formularies every January 1.

The Role of Medigap in Protecting HNW Retirees

Original Medicare has no out-of-pocket maximum. For a retiree with a serious health event, cost-sharing can accumulate significantly. A Medigap supplement plan — particularly a Plan G or Plan N — fills most of these gaps and provides cost predictability. For someone who values certainty in their financial plan, that predictability has real value.

3. Audit Your Part D Drug Plan Against Your Current Formulary

Why Formularies Change Every Year During Medicare Open Enrollment

Prescription drug plans update their formularies — the list of covered drugs — every year. A medication that was covered at a preferred tier in 2026 may be on a higher cost-sharing tier in 2027, or removed from the formulary entirely. Plan premiums also change. Medicare is required to send you an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) letter by September 30. If you have not read it, now is the time.

Use Medicare’s Plan Finder tool at Medicare.gov to compare your current plan against alternatives using your specific medications. The comparison is free and takes roughly 15 minutes. Even if you have been in the same plan for years, running this check annually is a sound habit.

The Medicare Part D Extra Help Program

For most HNW retirees, the Extra Help program for Part D costs will not apply — it is income- and asset-limited. What is relevant is the Part D IRMAA surcharge, which follows the same income-based structure as Part B. If your income is above IRMAA thresholds, you pay an additional monthly premium on your Part D plan on top of the plan’s own premium.

a close-up of a person using Medicare Plan Finder on a tablet computer, with reading glasses and a cup of coffee nearby, suggesting careful and deliberate research — Medicare open enrollment
a close-up of a person using Medicare Plan Finder on a tablet computer, with reading glasses and a cup of coffee nearby, suggesting careful and deliberate research

4. Evaluate Your Total Healthcare Cost Picture for 2027

What “Total Healthcare Cost” Means in Retirement

Medicare covers a great deal, but it does not cover everything. Dental, vision, and hearing care are largely excluded from Original Medicare. Long-term care is not covered.

As part of your Medicare open enrollment review, take stock of anticipated healthcare expenses in the coming year. If you have significant dental or vision needs on the horizon, factor that into your plan comparison. Dental discount plans and standalone dental insurance — not part of Medicare — may be worth exploring.

Coordinating Medicare with Long-Term Care Planning

Medicare open enrollment is also a natural prompt to revisit your long-term care strategy. Medicare covers short-term skilled nursing facility care under specific conditions — it is not a long-term care solution. For HNW families, the question is not whether to rely on Medicare for long-term care, but whether self-funding, a hybrid life/LTC policy, or a traditional LTC policy best fits your situation. Consult a qualified insurance and financial planning professional for your specific circumstances.

Comparing Key Medicare Plan Types

Feature Original Medicare + Medigap Medicare Advantage
Provider access Any Medicare-accepting provider nationwide Network-based; out-of-network often limited
Out-of-pocket maximum Medigap covers most gaps; predictable costs Has a statutory out-of-pocket maximum
Dental/vision/hearing Not covered; must purchase separately Often included; benefit depth varies by plan
Referral requirements None required May require referrals for specialists
Prior authorization Generally not required May be required for procedures and specialists
Premium cost Higher monthly premium (Part B + Medigap) Lower or $0 premium plans available

5. Understand How Roth Conversions and Capital Gains Affect Future Medicare Costs

The Two-Year Lookback and Why It Matters

This is one of the most underappreciated intersections of tax planning and Medicare planning. Because IRMAA is based on income from two years prior, a Roth conversion you execute in 2026 affects your 2028 Medicare premiums. A large capital gain realized in 2026 — from a business sale, a real estate transaction, or rebalancing a concentrated stock position — hits your Medicare costs in 2028.

HNW retirees who are actively managing their taxable income need to model this two-year lag explicitly. A Roth conversion that makes perfect tax sense in isolation may push you into a significantly higher IRMAA bracket two years later. The right answer is not necessarily to avoid the conversion — it is to understand the full cost and make an informed decision.

The IRMAA Appeal Process: Life-Changing Events

If your income drops significantly — through retirement, a business closure, or the death of a spouse — you can appeal your IRMAA determination using SSA Form SSA-44. This allows you to request that Medicare use a more recent tax year’s income rather than the two-year lookback. If you have experienced a qualifying life-changing event, this appeal process is worth pursuing promptly.

Learn more about IRMAA thresholds and the appeal process directly from the Social Security Administration at SSA.gov.

6. Coordinate Medicare with Your Employer or Retiree Coverage

When You Have Multiple Coverage Sources

Some HNW retirees — particularly those transitioning out of executive roles or still serving on boards — may have access to retiree health coverage through a former employer, or COBRA coverage from a spouse still working. The coordination rules between Medicare and employer coverage are complex and consequential. Getting the enrollment order wrong can result in permanent premium penalties.

The general rule: if you have coverage through an employer with 20 or more employees and your spouse is the active employee, that employer coverage is primary and Medicare is secondary. Once the active employment ends, Medicare becomes primary within a specific enrollment window. Missing that window can result in a permanent Part B late enrollment penalty.

Medicare and Health Savings Accounts

If you are still contributing to a Health Savings Account (HSA) through a high-deductible health plan, enrolling in any part of Medicare — including Part A — stops your ability to make new HSA contributions. This is a critical planning point for executives or business owners who are over 65 but delaying Medicare enrollment because of active employer coverage. You can still spend your existing HSA balance on qualified medical expenses, but new contributions must stop.

The IRS provides detailed guidance on HSAs and Medicare at IRS Publication 969. Review it with your tax advisor before making any enrollment decisions.

a financial advisor and client sitting across from each other at a clean desk with charts visible on a monitor in the background, in a professional office setting suggesting a planning conversation — Medicare open enrollment
a financial advisor and client sitting across from each other at a clean desk with charts visible on a monitor in the background, in a professional office setting suggesting a planning conversation

7. Work with an Advisor Who Integrates Medicare into Your Broader Financial Plan

Why Medicare Open Enrollment Is a Financial Planning Event

Most Medicare decisions are made in isolation — with an insurance agent focused on plan design, without reference to your tax situation, Roth conversion schedule, RMD strategy, or estate plan. For mass-market Medicare enrollees, that approach may be adequate. For high-net-worth retirees managing complex portfolios and significant taxable income, it leaves real money on the table.

Medicare open enrollment is a touchpoint in a larger financial planning conversation. The decisions you make about income recognition this year affect your Medicare premiums two years from now. The decisions you make about plan selection affect your healthcare cost exposure for the entire year ahead. These decisions deserve more than a 20-minute call with an insurance agent in October.

The Value of a Fiduciary Advisor in Medicare Planning

A financial advisor who acts as a fiduciary when providing investment-advisory services — and who understands the intersection of tax planning, retirement income, and Medicare — can help you think through these decisions in an integrated way. That means modeling your IRMAA exposure across multiple years, coordinating your Roth conversion strategy with your income thresholds, and reviewing your overall healthcare cost projection as part of your retirement income plan.

At Davies Wealth Management, Thomas Davies has 30 years of experience in financial services, beginning in 1996. The firm works with clients who have $500,000 or more in investable assets and focuses specifically on the complex financial planning needs of high-net-worth individuals, executives, and retirees in and around Stuart, Florida and beyond. If you would like to schedule a discovery conversation, we welcome the opportunity to review your situation.

Medicare Resources Worth Bookmarking

Frequently Asked Questions About Medicare Open Enrollment

When does Medicare open enrollment end in 2026?

Medicare open enrollment ends December 7, 2026. Any plan changes you make during this period — switching between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage, or changing your Part D drug plan — take effect January 1, 2027. Missing the deadline means you generally cannot change your coverage until the next open enrollment period, with limited exceptions.

How does Medicare open enrollment affect IRMAA surcharges?

Medicare open enrollment does not directly change your IRMAA surcharges — those are determined by your income from two years prior and are assessed by the Social Security Administration. However, the enrollment period is an important time to review your plan in light of your projected IRMAA costs for the coming year. If you recently experienced a qualifying life-changing event that reduced your income, you may be able to appeal your IRMAA determination using SSA Form SSA-44.

Can I switch from Medicare Advantage back to Original Medicare during open enrollment?

Yes. Medicare open enrollment allows you to disenroll from a Medicare Advantage plan and return to Original Medicare, and to simultaneously enroll in a standalone Part D drug plan. The important caveat for high-net-worth retirees is that returning to Original Medicare does not automatically grant you Medigap coverage — Medigap enrollment outside of your initial enrollment period may be subject to medical underwriting in most states. Consult a qualified insurance professional before making this switch.

How should I evaluate my Part D drug plan each year during Medicare open enrollment?

Start with the Annual Notice of Change letter your current plan is required to send you by September 30. Then use Medicare’s Plan Finder tool at Medicare.gov to compare your current plan against alternatives using your specific list of medications. Look at total annual cost — premiums plus estimated drug cost-sharing — not just the monthly premium. Formularies and pricing change every year, so this comparison is worth running annually even if you plan to stay in your current plan.

What is the relationship between Roth conversions and Medicare premiums?

A Roth conversion increases your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) in the year the conversion is taken. Because IRMAA surcharges on Medicare Part B and Part D are based on your MAGI from two years prior, a large Roth conversion today will affect your Medicare premiums two years from now. This is not a reason to avoid Roth conversions — which offer significant long-term tax advantages for HNW families — but it is a planning variable that should be explicitly modeled when sizing your conversion each year. Consult a qualified tax and financial planning professional for your specific situation.

Key Takeaways Before the Medicare Open Enrollment Deadline

The December 7 Medicare open enrollment deadline arrives quickly, and the financial stakes for high-net-worth retirees are higher than most people realize. Here is a concise checklist to work through before the window closes:

  1. Check your current IRMAA bracket and project whether income changes will move you into a higher or lower bracket in future years
  2. Compare Original Medicare + Medigap vs. Medicare Advantage with fresh eyes — do not assume last year’s decision is still the right one
  3. Run your Part D formulary comparison using Medicare.gov Plan Finder with your current medication list
  4. Assess your total 2027 healthcare cost exposure including out-of-pocket maximums, dental, and vision
  5. Model how income decisions in 2026 — particularly Roth conversions and capital gains — affect your 2028 Medicare premiums
  6. Review coordination with employer or retiree coverage to avoid enrollment penalties or HSA contribution violations
  7. Integrate your Medicare decisions into a broader financial plan with a fiduciary advisor, not in isolation

Medicare open enrollment is not a paperwork exercise — it is a financial planning decision with multi-year consequences. For families managing significant wealth, getting it right is worth the time and the professional guidance.


Download Our Medicare IRMAA Planning Guide

If you are navigating IRMAA surcharges, Roth conversion timing, or the complex interaction between your income and your Medicare costs, our Medicare IRMAA Planning Guide walks through the thresholds, the strategies, and the planning questions you should be asking. Download the Medicare IRMAA Planning Guide here.

Ready for personalized guidance from a fee-based fiduciary? Thomas Davies and the team at Davies Wealth Management work with individuals and families with $500,000 or more in investable assets. Book a complimentary phone call here.

This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Consult a qualified financial, tax, and insurance professional for guidance specific to your situation. Davies Wealth Management is an investment adviser registered with the State of Florida. When providing investment-advisory services, the firm acts as a fiduciary. Insurance and annuity products may involve commissions, which are separately disclosed.


This content is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute individualized investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Investment-advisory services are offered by Davies Wealth Management, LLC, an investment adviser registered with the State of Florida. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Please consult appropriately qualified financial, tax, or legal professionals regarding your specific circumstances. This content was produced with AI assistance and may contain errors. Please verify any figures or claims before relying on them.



Listen & Watch

Prefer audio or video? We’ve got you covered.

Podcast Episode

Video

Take the Financial Wellness Quiz

Discover your financial health score in 2 minutes — personalized insights, zero obligation.

Take the Quiz

Ready to Talk?

Book a complimentary Fiduciary Audit with Thomas Davies, CFS®

Book a Call

Davies Wealth Management · Fee-Based Fiduciary · Stuart, FL